Earbuds vs. headphones for a daily commute

We spent a month alternating between noise-cancelling earbuds and over-ear headphones on trains, buses and planes.

Where earbuds win

Pocketable, no hair or glasses conflict, and modern ANC handles engine rumble well.

Where headphones win

Longer battery, better isolation on a loud plane, more comfortable for five-hour sessions.

Our pick

For most commutes, a good pair of ANC earbuds is enough. Pair them with a watch that controls playback and you rarely touch the phone.